So wait, are we perming him for this?
I think we should ask @Mahogany for his side if we are actually perming someone for trolling. SpydyrByte, it sounds like he is trolling you. Being
is really sounding unnecessary. It sounds like he isn't stalking, he is just dedicated to trolling because you are giving him a reaction. Keep in mind, I am not saying this is ok to do. This does warrant a punishment. At most I would say a day or week ban would suffice, but if we are going for a perm, it is incredibly unnecessary.
Also, if he was gagged and muted a lot, this is sounding like another Sirflash incident. (Which we removed his perm and gave him a week ban because there was never any action past a gag/mute.) If this post is indeed trying to permaban Mahogany, we should be following the the order of punishment that is in the admin handbook
Everything You Need To Know [admins, Servers, Handbook, Etc.]
Warn, slay/mute/gag, kick, day ban, week ban (dependant on rule), permanent ban
;TLDR;
-1 for perm
+/-0 for day or week ban
Waiting for @Mahogany to reply, vote possibly will change.